48. Echo. Adam Rex. 2025. 48 pages. [Source: Library] [3 stars, picture book, friendship]
First sentence: Junior Junior was born in a big house on the side of a mountain...and the echo was born soon after.
Premise/plot: Junior Junior's 'best friend' is the echo on the other side of the mountain who always, always echoes exactly what he says....and nothing else. Is it a perfect friendship? No. It depends on what Junior Junior says to start the conversation! For example, when he says MINE! it can lead to misunderstanding. When a girl moves in across the street, Junior Junior struggles with this 'new' company. She does not repeat after him or echo his words and sentiments. She has a mind of her own. Can Junior Junior make peace with this new potential-friend?
My thoughts: One of the 'rules' (more like guidelines really) is that you review the book in hand and not the book you wish it was. Such is the case with Echo. I thought the concept had potential. I did. I didn't "love" the illustrations. (Illustrations are subjective, of course, you may absolutely love them). The narrative was interesting, for the most part. It also uses the word 'idiot' as an insult. This may or may not bother parents.
Personally, I was wanting the echo to be a literal echo. There is still a chance that it is an imaginary friend only. But it's depicted as a literal kid on the other side of the mountain. (Again, maybe imaginary maybe not). The Echo-friend is just as lifeless as you imagine, but dressed differently then Junior Junior so not a reflection.
The message is the same anyway: new neighbor girl is a better friend because she has a voice and opinion and echo-kid is not.
© 2025 Becky Laney of Young Readers